ottoojala.com/blog/what-are-ideas-worth/

What are ideas worth?


Feature image

Are ideas worth nothing or everything now?

Sharing GIFs of my progress is something I’m used to doing, and something I’m not willing to give up, even though it makes little sense considering how easy it is for someone to copy-paste your idea into an LLM and claim the result as theirs. The more popular your post is on some social media platform, the more obvious it becomes that your idea is going to get copied - and the game even published on some store. You’re essentially sharing something new you’ve come up with, proving its potential on social media, and giving it up for free for the zero-effort cloners. What people used to say is ideas are worthless and it’s the execution that counts, does it still apply?

Obviously some ideas are easier to copy than others, but the kind of games I’m into making are often the easy-to-copy ones. I certainly did not leave social media just to “hide” my game development GIFs from the public, or to prevent them from “trending”, but I am curious about if this makes any difference to how “safe” my GIFs are from the cloners. Or if it’s actually just worse as there’s no popular evidence of me coming up with something first, with only the clones getting visibility online. Most likely no-one cares, and that’s fine :—)

All in all, I am so grateful I made my commercial games years ago, when it took a little bit more effort to make a crappy clone of something. And I’m still glad no idea can be owned, and there are no copyrights for ideas.

In the post’s GIF is a prototype, inspired by my Pocket Nova. It’s silly and only kind of makes sense, but I haven’t seen games like it - it’s the good old slingshot controls, but using a joystick. Perhaps something like this could be a thing as these Steam Deck-like devices are becoming more popular? Joystick-only shared-controller games, hmm.

P.S.

Maybe I shouldn’t have just taken a look at how many of the “new and popular” games on itch.io are made AI-assisted. How does one make games in a way that it still feels significant? Maybe I should get more into hardware - it’s a proven path for us reaching our midlife crisis anyway…

P.P.S.

After reading this, I’m not sure if I’m at the 3rd or 4th stage of grief (bargaining or depression). Maybe it is just what it is. There’s nothing much I can do. (This is me trying to jump straight to the 5th stage, acceptance.)


Share on Bluesky / Share on Mastodon / Copy link to post


Scroll to top
Under construction